Jakobe Law

Appeals · Arizona

How Criminal Appeals Work in Arizona

An appeal is not a second trial. Here is how a criminal appeal actually works in Arizona — the strict 20-day deadline, who can appeal, and what the court can and cannot do.


An appeal is not a second trial

A criminal appeal is one of the most misunderstood parts of the system. It is not a do-over of the trial. No new evidence is presented, no witnesses testify again, and the appellate court does not decide whether it would have reached a different verdict. The court reviews the written record of what happened below — the transcripts, the rulings, the exhibits — and asks a narrower question: did a legal error occur that affected the outcome? Winning an appeal is the work of finding those errors in a cold record and showing why they mattered.

The 20-day deadline

The most important thing to know about an Arizona appeal is how little time there is to start one. A notice of appeal must be filed with the sentencing court within 20 days of sentencing. Miss that window and the right to a direct appeal is generally lost. This is not a deadline that forgives delay, which is why the decision to appeal has to be made quickly, often before the weight of the sentence has settled.

Who can appeal

If you were convicted after a trial, you have the right to a direct appeal. If you pleaded guilty, the rule is different: in Arizona, a guilty plea generally waives the right to a direct appeal, and your path to relief is a petition for post-conviction relief under Rule 33 instead. Knowing which road applies to your case is the first step, because the deadlines and procedures are not the same.

Where the appeal goes

A direct appeal is heard by the Arizona Court of Appeals — Division One or Division Two, depending on where the case was tried. A three-judge panel reviews the case and issues a written decision. Certain cases, and further review after the Court of Appeals rules, can reach the Arizona Supreme Court.

How an appeal unfolds

After the notice of appeal, the trial record is assembled and the court reporters prepare the transcripts — a step that alone can take weeks or months. Then comes the heart of the appeal, the briefing: the appellant files an opening brief identifying each claimed error and explaining, with the record and the law, why it requires relief; the State files an answering brief; and the appellant may file a reply. Once briefing is complete, the case is assigned to a panel, oral argument is held if the court grants it, and the panel issues its decision. The whole process commonly takes many months, sometimes more than a year.

What the court can do

If the court finds a harmful legal error, it can reverse the conviction, order a new trial, or send the case back for resentencing. If it finds no error, or decides the error did not affect the outcome, it affirms. Many issues must have been raised at trial to be fully considered on appeal; an issue not preserved below is reviewed under a stricter standard, which is one more reason the trial record and the appeal are deeply connected.

Why the brief decides the case

An appeal is won or lost on the brief. There is no jury to persuade and usually little or no testimony — there is a written argument read by judges who know the law and have the record in front of them. The work is in identifying the issues that matter, framing them precisely, and marshaling the record and authority behind each one. Ms. Jakobe has spent her career writing these briefs before the Arizona Court of Appeals and the Arizona Supreme Court, and she takes appeals selectively, where the issues are real.

The bottom line

If you are considering an appeal in Arizona, the clock is already running — the notice of appeal is due within 20 days of sentencing. Whether you were convicted at trial or resolved your case by plea determines the path, and both carry strict deadlines. The sooner the record is reviewed, the stronger the appeal.

Carissa A. Jakobe, Phoenix criminal defense attorney

Carissa A. Jakobe

Phoenix criminal defense attorney, twenty-one years in practice.