Jakobe Law

Post-Conviction Relief · Arizona

Post-Conviction Relief in Arizona: Rule 32 and Rule 33 Explained

When the appeal is over, post-conviction relief may still be available in Arizona. Here is how Rule 32 and Rule 33 petitions work, what they can raise, and the deadlines that control them.


What post-conviction relief is

Post-conviction relief, often called PCR, is the stage that comes after a direct appeal — or, for some defendants, in place of one. It is a challenge to a conviction or sentence filed back in the trial court that imposed it, not in the appellate court. Its purpose is to raise problems that an ordinary appeal cannot reach, because many of the most serious issues in a case live outside the trial record. Post-conviction relief is where they are brought to light.

Rule 32 or Rule 33 — which one applies

In 2020, Arizona divided post-conviction relief into two rules. Rule 32 governs defendants who were convicted and sentenced after a trial. Rule 33 governs defendants who pleaded guilty or no contest. The distinction matters, because a defendant who pleaded guilty generally gave up the right to a direct appeal; for that person, the first Rule 33 petition is an “of-right” proceeding that takes the place of the appeal they never had. Either way, the petition is filed in the same court that entered the judgment.

What post-conviction relief can raise

This is where PCR does work no appeal can. The grounds include ineffective assistance of counsel — a claim that almost always must be raised in a PCR rather than on direct appeal, because it depends on facts outside the trial record; newly discovered material evidence that could change the result; a significant change in the law that now applies to the case; an illegal sentence, or one the court had no authority to impose; and actual innocence. These are not disagreements with the verdict. They are specific, provable defects in how the conviction or sentence came about.

The deadlines

The deadlines are strict, and missing them usually ends the matter. In general, the notice beginning a PCR must be filed within 90 days of sentencing, or — for a defendant who took a direct appeal first — within 30 days after the Court of Appeals issues its mandate, whichever is later. Some grounds are treated differently: a claim based on newly discovered evidence, a change in the law, or actual innocence may be raised later, but only within a reasonable time after the basis for it is discovered, and the petition must explain the delay. Because the rules are unforgiving, the time to evaluate a PCR is as soon as the appeal is decided, not months afterward.

How a PCR proceeds

A PCR begins with a notice filed in the trial court, which may also request appointment of counsel. The heart of the case is the petition, which must state each ground and support it with facts — from the record, from transcripts, and often from affidavits and evidence gathered outside the original case. The State responds. The court may dismiss the petition, order an evidentiary hearing where witnesses testify, or grant relief, which can mean a new trial, a corrected sentence, or a vacated conviction. Unlike an appeal, a PCR can develop new facts, which is exactly why it reaches claims an appeal cannot.

The bottom line

If a conviction or sentence was the product of ineffective counsel, a violation of a constitutional right, new evidence, actual innocence, a change in the law, or an illegal sentence, post-conviction relief may be the way to challenge it — but the deadlines move quickly after the appeal. The sooner the case is reviewed, the more that can be done.

Carissa A. Jakobe, Phoenix criminal defense attorney

Carissa A. Jakobe

Phoenix criminal defense attorney, twenty-one years in practice.