Jakobe Law

Criminal Defense · Arizona

Diversion in Arizona

What diversion is, who decides, how it is usually obtained, how to comply, and what happens if you do not complete it — answered plainly.


Diversion is the one result in a criminal case that can end without a conviction and without a trial. It is also easy to lose. The answers below explain how diversion works in Arizona, how people usually get it, and what it takes to finish it. They are general information, not legal advice; whether diversion is available or wise in a specific case is a decision to make with a criminal defense attorney.

What is diversion in Arizona?

Diversion is an agreement with the prosecutor. The prosecutor stops the case while you complete a set of conditions. If you complete them, the charge is dismissed and there is no conviction. Arizona law also calls this deferred prosecution. A county attorney’s program is defined in A.R.S. § 11-361 as supervision in which prosecution is deferred or diverted before a guilty plea or a trial. City prosecutors run their own programs for misdemeanors under A.R.S. § 9-500.22.

Who decides if I get diversion in Arizona?

The prosecutor decides. Under A.R.S. § 11-365, the county attorney has sole discretion to decide whether to divert or defer a prosecution. A judge cannot order the prosecutor to offer it, and no one has a right to it. Each prosecutor’s office sets its own guidelines, so the same charge may qualify in one county or city and not in another.

How do you get diversion in Arizona?

There are two common paths. In the first, the prosecutor’s office screens the case and makes the offer on its own, usually on a lower-level charge against a person with little or no record. In the second, the defense attorney asks for it. The attorney goes to the prosecutor early, before any plea, and shows why this person and this case belong in diversion: no prior record, steady work, family, treatment already started, restitution ready to be paid, and the weak points in the State’s evidence. Many diversion offers exist only because a defense attorney asked.

Who is eligible for diversion in Arizona?

It depends on the office and the charge. Prosecutors look at the offense, the person’s criminal history, whether anyone was hurt, whether a weapon was involved, and how much restitution is owed. Diversion is most common for first-time, non-violent offenses, including many drug possession cases. A city program cannot accept a case in which a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument was discharged, used, or threatened. A.R.S. § 9-500.22.

Do I have to admit guilt to get diversion?

Often, yes, in some form. Many programs require a signed statement admitting the facts of the offense, and a city program may require a guilty plea before entry. Read every page before you sign. If you do not finish the program, the State may try to use that statement against you when the case starts again. This is one reason to have an attorney review the agreement first.

What happens in court when diversion starts?

The prosecutor files a motion asking the court to suspend the case. The motion must come with your signed consent, and your attorney signs it too. The court then suspends the prosecution for the period the motion requests, which cannot be longer than two years. If you are in custody, the court may order your release. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 38.1.

How do I comply with a diversion program?

Do every condition, on time, and keep proof. The conditions are set out in the agreement and usually include an assessment, classes or counseling, drug or alcohol testing, restitution to any victim, and program fees. You must also stay out of new trouble and keep your address and phone number current with the program. Finish early when you can. Keep every receipt, certificate, and test result. If a problem comes up, such as a missed class, a positive test, or a payment you cannot make, tell your attorney before the deadline passes, not after.

How long does diversion take in Arizona?

Most programs run from a few months to a year. The length depends on the charge and on what the assessment recommends. The court may not suspend a case for diversion for more than two years. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 38.1.

What happens when I complete diversion?

The prosecutor tells the court that you completed the program, and the court must dismiss the charge. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 38.3. You are not convicted.

What happens if I don't complete diversion?

The case starts again. The prosecutor files a notice that you did not meet the conditions, and the court must lift the suspension and order the prosecution to resume. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 38.2. You then face the original charge and its full penalties. Any statement you signed to enter the program may be offered against you. The prosecutor may give a second chance, but is not required to.

Is diversion the same as probation?

No. Probation is a sentence. It comes after a conviction. Diversion comes before any conviction and is meant to prevent one. A person who completes probation still has a conviction. A person who completes diversion does not.

Should I accept a diversion offer?

Usually, but not always. Diversion ends the case without a conviction, and that is hard to beat. It also costs time and money, it may require an admission, and failing it leaves you worse off than before. If the State’s case is weak, a dismissal or an acquittal may be the better goal. Have an attorney review the evidence and the agreement before you decide.

Carissa A. Jakobe, Phoenix criminal defense attorney

Carissa A. Jakobe

Phoenix criminal defense attorney, twenty-one years in practice.