Jakobe Law

Criminal Defense · Arizona

What Is a Confrontation Call?

What a confrontation call is, why police use it, how it is used at trial, and what to say if one comes in — answered plainly.


A confrontation call is one of the most common tools police use when a case comes down to one person’s word against another’s. The call is recorded, the suspect usually has no idea police are listening, and the recording can become the heart of the State’s case. The answers below explain how these calls work in Arizona and what to do if one comes in. They are general information, not legal advice; what to do in a specific situation is a decision to make with a criminal defense attorney.

What is a confrontation call?

A confrontation call is a recorded phone call. The alleged victim calls the suspect, at the direction of law enforcement and in the presence of law enforcement, while the conversation is recorded. The officers sit beside the victim, listen, and often tell the victim what to say. It is also called a pretext call or a controlled call.

Why do police use confrontation calls?

Police want the suspect to say something on tape. It might be an admission, an apology, a detail, or a denial that sounds wrong. These calls are most common in cases with little else to go on, such as sexual abuse and domestic violence. The victim is prompted, the call is recorded, and the recording is saved for a jury.

Is it legal for police to record a confrontation call?

Yes. Arizona is a one-party consent state. Under A.R.S. § 13-3012(9), a call may be recorded when one person on the call consents. In a confrontation call, the victim consents, so the suspect does not need to know. Having the police in the room does not change that.

What if I was already charged when the call was made?

That can change everything. Once formal charges are filed, the right to counsel attaches, and the State generally may not deliberately draw statements out of a charged person, directly or through an agent, without a lawyer present. A confrontation call made after charges are filed, at the direction of police, may be open to a motion to suppress. This is a serious issue and one to raise with a criminal defense attorney right away.

Can a confrontation call be used as evidence against me at trial?

Yes. Very often it is the State’s case. When there is no physical evidence, or when the case is old, the recording may be the most important thing the State has. What a defendant says on the call is generally admissible as a statement of a party opponent, and the jury hears it in the defendant’s own voice. The victim’s side of the conversation usually comes in as well, to give context.

Can saying “I’m sorry,” or staying silent, on a confrontation call be used against me?

Yes. The State will present an apology as an admission, and it will present silence the same way. A prosecutor will tell the jury that an innocent person would have denied it right away. People apologize and go quiet for many reasons, but the jury hears the recording, not the reasons. The safest course is to say nothing about the accusation at all.

What should I do if someone accuses me and then calls me?

Say this: “I cannot talk right now. Can I call you later? I am in the middle of something.” Then get off the phone. Do not discuss the accusation, do not defend yourself, and do not try to change the person’s mind, because you cannot know who is listening or recording. Then speak with a criminal defense attorney before you do anything else. Trying to persuade an accuser to change a story can lead to new charges, such as tampering with a witness.

Can a victim record a call with the police?

Yes. Arizona is a one-party consent state, so a person who is on a call may record it without telling the other person. That is true when the police are directing the call, listening in, and recording alongside the victim. The victim is a party to the conversation, and the victim’s consent is what makes the recording lawful. The same rule means a victim may also record a call alone, without any officers involved.

Carissa A. Jakobe, Phoenix criminal defense attorney

Carissa A. Jakobe

Phoenix criminal defense attorney, twenty-one years in practice.